Philosophy: The Big Questions study guide · Lesson 1 of 15

What Is Philosophy?

The Five Branches · Great Divides · How Philosophers Argue

This is the lesson's study guide from the FlashFeed app, plus its key facts and a self-test.

What you'll be able to do

  • Match each of the five classical branches to the core question it asks
  • Recognize each branch by its definition and set philosophy apart from its neighbors
  • Contrast rationalism/empiricism, a priori/a posteriori, and analytic/synthetic knowledge
  • Distinguish the great metaphysical divides and identify the framework that judges an action by its consequences.
  • Apply the tools of valid argument: validity, soundness, inference, and fallacies

Philosophy (from the Greek philosophia, "love of wisdom") is the rigorous, rational examination of the most fundamental questions about existence, knowledge, values, reason, mind, and language. Western tradition organizes it into five classical branches, each defined by a core question and a stubborn key problem. Around these sit several sub-disciplines, and around all of it sits the question of what makes philosophy different from science and religion.

What Philosophy Is

The word itself is a promise: philo (love) + sophia (wisdom). Philosophy is not the possession of wisdom but the disciplined pursuit of it. A philosopher does not accept claims on authority or tradition; she interrogates the assumptions hidden inside them. The tools are reason and argument, not faith, revelation, or experiment alone.

The Five Branches

The five classical branches are metaphysics, epistemology, ethics, logic, and aesthetics. Each owns a core question: What is real? What can we know? How should we live? What is valid reasoning? What is beauty? Together they map the whole territory of human inquiry that can be pursued by thought.

Metaphysics

Metaphysics asks what is real? It studies existence, substance, causality, time, and free will — the deep structure of reality beneath appearances. Its key problems include whether the mind is distinct from matter and whether our choices are genuinely free or causally fixed.

Epistemology

Epistemology asks what can we know, and how? It studies the sources, limits, and justification of knowledge. Its central problem is distinguishing genuine knowledge from mere belief or lucky guesswork — and answering the skeptic who doubts we can know anything at all.

Ethics

Ethics asks how should we live? It studies moral principles, right action, virtue, and justice. The key problem is grounding moral claims: are they objective truths, expressions of feeling, or conventions that vary by culture?

Logic

Logic asks what is valid reasoning? It studies the forms that make inference reliable — validity, soundness, formal systems — and catalogs the fallacies that make it fail. Logic is the toolkit the other four branches use to argue well.

Aesthetics

Aesthetics asks what is beauty, and what is art? It studies taste, creativity, the sublime, and meaning in art. A key problem is whether beauty lives in the object or only in the eye of the beholder.

Philosophy's Sub-Disciplines

Beyond the five branches lie focused sub-disciplines that apply philosophical method to a domain: political philosophy (justice, authority, the state), philosophy of mind (consciousness, the mind–body link), philosophy of science (what makes a theory scientific), philosophy of language (meaning and reference), and philosophy of religion (arguments for and against God).

Philosophy vs. Science and Religion

A useful contrast: science answers how through observation and experiment; religion often answers why through faith and revelation; philosophy answers why through reason and argument. Science tests hypotheses against the world; philosophy examines the concepts and assumptions science itself relies on — and many questions (about justice, meaning, or what counts as evidence) cannot be settled in a laboratory at all.

Philosophy runs on a handful of foundational distinctions — paired opposites that recur across centuries of debate. Master these and most arguments become readable: you can spot which side a thinker takes and what is at stake. Here are the great divides every student must know, drawn from epistemology, metaphysics, and ethics.

Rationalism vs. Empiricism

The deepest split in epistemology concerns the source of knowledge. Rationalism holds that reason is primary and that the mind contains innate ideas we can unfold through thought (Descartes, Leibniz). Empiricism holds that sense experience is primary and the mind begins as a blank slate, filled only by what the senses deliver (Locke, Hume). Kant later tried to fuse the two.

A Priori vs. A Posteriori

A related distinction concerns how a claim is justified. A priori knowledge is justified independently of experience — "7 + 5 = 12" needs no observation. A posteriori knowledge depends on experience — "water boils at 100°C" must be checked against the world. Rationalists prize the a priori; empiricists are suspicious of how much it can deliver.

Dualism vs. Monism

In metaphysics, dualism says reality has two fundamentally different kinds of substance — typically mind and matter (Descartes). Monism says reality is ultimately one kind of thing: for Spinoza, a single substance he called God or Nature; for idealists, mind; for materialists, matter. The mind–body problem lives in this gap.

Idealism vs. Materialism

A particular monist contest. Idealism holds that reality is fundamentally mental — mind or ideas are the bedrock (Berkeley, Hegel). Materialism (or physicalism) holds that only physical things exist, and the mind is ultimately brain processes. Each must explain away the thing the other treats as basic.

Deontology vs. Consequentialism vs. Virtue Ethics

Ethics offers three great rival frameworks. Deontology judges actions by duties and rules, binding regardless of outcome (Kant's Categorical Imperative). Consequentialism judges actions by their results — utilitarianism aims to maximize well-being (Bentham, Mill). Virtue ethics shifts focus from acts to character, asking what a person of good character — aiming at eudaimonia, flourishing — would do (Aristotle).

Analytic vs. Synthetic

Kant's distinction sorts truths by where their truth comes from. An analytic statement is true by definition: "all bachelors are unmarried" unpacks the meaning of its terms. A synthetic statement adds new information about the world: "the sun is 93 million miles from Earth." The combination Kant cared about most — the synthetic a priori — is informative yet knowable without experience.

Necessity vs. Contingency

A modal distinction about ways things could be. A necessary truth could not have been otherwise (a triangle has three sides; in any possible world this holds). A contingent truth happens to be true but could have been false (you are reading this now). The distinction underwrites arguments about God, identity, and the limits of possibility.

Philosophy is not just a set of conclusions; it is a method of getting there. What separates a philosophical claim from an opinion is the argument behind it — a structure of reasons offered in support. This part covers how arguments are built, how to judge them, the patterns good reasoning follows, the traps it falls into, and a couple of classic tools of the trade.

What Is an Argument

In philosophy an argument is not a quarrel but a structure: one or more premises offered as support for a conclusion. The premises are the reasons; the conclusion is the claim they are meant to establish. Evaluating an argument means asking two separate things — is the logic good, and are the premises actually true?

Deductive vs. Inductive Reasoning

Deductive reasoning moves from general premises to a conclusion that follows with certainty: if the premises are true, the conclusion must be true. Inductive reasoning moves from observations to a general conclusion that is only probable: the sun has risen every day, so it will rise tomorrow. Deduction guarantees; induction generalizes and can be overturned by new evidence.

Validity vs. Soundness

These are the two great virtues of a deductive argument, and they are not the same. An argument is valid if its conclusion follows logically from its premises — the form is correct, regardless of whether the premises are true. It is sound only if it is valid and all its premises are actually true. A valid argument can have a false conclusion (from false premises); only a sound one guarantees truth.

The Syllogism

Aristotle's syllogism is the classic deductive form: a major premise, a minor premise, and a conclusion. "All humans are mortal; Socrates is human; therefore Socrates is mortal." The conclusion is locked in by the two premises — the model of valid form that logic studied for two thousand years.

Modus Ponens

Modus ponens ("the way that affirms") is the most fundamental valid inference: If P, then Q. P. Therefore Q. If it is raining the ground is wet; it is raining; therefore the ground is wet. Its mirror image, modus tollens, denies the consequent: if P then Q, not-Q, therefore not-P.

The Principle of Non-Contradiction

Aristotle's principle of non-contradiction says nothing can both be and not be in the same respect at the same time. A statement and its denial cannot both be true together. This is often called the bedrock of rational thought — abandon it and any claim can be "proved."

Common Fallacies

A fallacy is an error in reasoning that can look persuasive. Three to know: the ad hominem attacks the arguer instead of the argument; the straw man refutes a distorted, weaker version of an opponent's view; the false dichotomy presents only two options when more exist. Spotting fallacies is half of thinking clearly.

Dialectic and Ockham's Razor

Two enduring tools. Dialectic is reasoning through opposition — Socratic questioning that exposes contradictions, or Hegel's movement from thesis and antithesis toward synthesis. Ockham's razor is a principle of economy: among competing explanations that fit the evidence, prefer the one with the fewest assumptions.

Testing Whether an Argument Is Sound

To test soundness, work in order: identify the conclusion, list the premises, check that the conclusion validly follows from them, then check whether each premise is actually true. Only if both the form is valid and every premise is true is the argument sound — and only then must you accept the conclusion.

Key terms

Metaphysics
The branch of philosophy that asks what is real — studying existence, substance, causality, time, and free will.
Epistemology
The branch of philosophy that studies knowledge — its sources, limits, and justification.
A priori vs. a posteriori
Knowledge justified independently of experience (like '7+5=12') versus knowledge that depends on experience (like 'water boils at 100°C').
Analytic vs. synthetic
Kant's split between truths that hold by definition ('all bachelors are unmarried') and truths that add new information about the world ('the sun is 93 million miles away').
Validity
A deductive argument has this property when its conclusion follows logically from its premises — the form is correct even if the premises are false.
Soundness
A deductive argument has this property when it is valid AND all of its premises are actually true, which guarantees a true conclusion.

Key concepts

Metaphysics

  • One of the five classical branches of philosophy, mapping the deep structure of reality that lies beneath appearances.
  • Its single core question is blunt: what is real?
  • It studies existence, substance, causality, and time, and asks whether mind is distinct from matter and whether our choices are truly free.

Epistemology

  • One of the five classical branches, this one preoccupied with belief, justification, and answering the skeptic.
  • Its core question: what can we know, and how?
  • It studies the sources and limits of knowledge, above all how to tell genuine knowledge from mere belief or a lucky guess.

Ethics

  • One of the five classical branches, focused on how a person ought to act.
  • Its core question: how should we live?
  • It studies moral principles, virtue, and justice, and wrestles with whether right and wrong are objective truths, mere feelings, or cultural conventions.

Logic

  • One of the five classical branches, the very toolkit the other four rely on to argue well.
  • Its core question: what makes reasoning valid?
  • It studies validity, soundness, and formal systems, and catalogs the fallacies that make an inference fail.

Aesthetics

  • One of the five classical branches, the one that ventures into taste, creativity, and the sublime.
  • Its core question: what is beauty, and what is art?
  • A signature puzzle it poses: does beauty live in the object itself, or only in the eye of the beholder?

Key facts

The Love of Wisdom

The word philosophy comes from the Greek philosophia — philo (love) + sophia (wisdom). It is the rigorous, rational examination of the most fundamental questions about existence, knowledge, values, reason, mind, and language. A philosopher accepts nothing on authority or tradition, but interrogates the assumptions hidden inside every claim — using reason and argument rather than faith or experiment alone.

The Five Branches of Philosophy

Western philosophy is classically divided into five branches, each owning a core question. Metaphysics: What is real? Epistemology: What can we know? Ethics: How should we live? Logic: What is valid reasoning? Aesthetics: What is beauty and art? Together they map the whole territory of questions that can be pursued by thought rather than by experiment alone.

Logic: The Study of Validity

Logic is the branch of philosophy that asks what makes reasoning valid, studying validity, soundness, and the many kinds of fallacies that can undermine an argument.

What Philosophers Mean by an Argument

In philosophy an argument is not a quarrel but a structure: one or more premises offered as support for a conclusion. The premises are the reasons; the conclusion is the claim they establish. Evaluating an argument means asking two separate questions — is the logic good (does the conclusion follow?), and are the premises actually true?

Aristotle's Syllogism

The syllogism is the classic deductive form, devised by Aristotle: a major premise, a minor premise, and a conclusion locked in by the two. All humans are mortal; Socrates is human; therefore Socrates is mortal. If the premises are true and the form valid, the conclusion cannot be false. This structure anchored logic for two thousand years.

The Principle of Non-Contradiction

Aristotle's principle of non-contradiction states that nothing can both be and not be in the same respect at the same time — a statement and its denial cannot both be true together. It is often called the bedrock of rational thought: abandon it and any claim, however absurd, can be 'proved.'

Deduction vs Induction

Deductive reasoning guarantees its conclusion when the premises are true, while inductive reasoning only makes a conclusion probable, open to being overturned by new evidence.

Matched pairs

Each item on the left goes with the one on the right.

Ethics
The branch asking how we should live — moral principles, right action, virtue, and justice
Logic
The branch studying valid reasoning — validity, soundness, formal systems, and fallacies
Aesthetics
The branch studying beauty and art — taste, creativity, the sublime, and meaning in art
Philosophy of mind
The sub-discipline studying consciousness and the relationship between mind and body
Rationalism vs. Empiricism
Reason and innate ideas as the source of knowledge (Descartes) vs. sense experience as the source (Locke, Hume)
Dualism vs. Monism
Reality has two kinds of substance, mind and matter (Descartes), vs. reality is ultimately one substance (Spinoza)
Idealism vs. Materialism
Reality is fundamentally mental, made of mind or ideas, vs. only physical things exist and mind is brain processes
Necessity vs. Contingency
A truth that could not have been otherwise (a triangle has three sides) vs. one that happens to be true but could have been false
Deductive vs. Inductive reasoning
From premises to a conclusion that follows with certainty vs. from observations to a conclusion that is only probable
Modus ponens
The basic valid inference: If P then Q; P; therefore Q
Ockham's razor
Among competing explanations that fit the evidence, prefer the one with the fewest assumptions

Step by step

Testing whether an argument is sound

  1. Identify the conclusion — the claim being argued for
  2. List the premises offered as support
  3. Check validity: does the conclusion follow logically from the premises?
  4. Check the premises: is each one actually true?
  5. Conclude sound only if it is both valid and all premises are true

Self-test

Answer each question from memory, then check your work against the answer key.

  1. 1. Which core question does metaphysics ask?

    1. AWhat is knowable?
    2. BWhat is real?
    3. CWhat is right?
    4. DWhat is beautiful?
  1. 2. Which branch asks 'What can we know, and how?'

    1. AMetaphysics
    2. BEthics
    3. CLogic
    4. DEpistemology
  2. 3. The core question 'How should we live?' belongs to which branch?

    1. AEpistemology
    2. BLogic
    3. CEthics
    4. DAesthetics
  3. 4. Logic is the branch that asks which core question?

    1. AWhat is valid reasoning?
    2. BWhat is genuine knowledge?
    3. CWhat is ultimate reality?
    4. DWhat is right action?
  4. 5. Which pairing of a branch with its core question is correct?

    1. AMetaphysics — What can we know?
    2. BEthics — What is real?
    3. CAesthetics — What is beauty?
    4. DLogic — How should we live?
  5. 6. Which core question does epistemology ask?

    1. AWhat is real?
    2. BHow should we live?
    3. CWhat is valid reasoning?
    4. DWhat can we know, and how?
  6. 7. Epistemology is the branch of philosophy devoted to answering which question?

    1. AWhat is beauty, and what is art?
    2. BWhat can we know, and how?
    3. CHow should we live?
    4. DWhat is real?
  7. 8. Which core question defines aesthetics as a branch of philosophy?

    1. AWhat is beauty, and what is art?
    2. BWhat is valid reasoning?
    3. CWhat is real?
    4. DHow should we live?
  8. 9. Aesthetics is the branch of philosophy that asks:

    1. AWhat can we know, and how?
    2. BWhat is beauty, and what is art?
    3. CHow should we live?
    4. DWhat is valid reasoning?
  9. 10. What best distinguishes philosophy from empirical science?

    1. AIt settles questions by faith and revelation rather than testing hypotheses against the world
    2. BIt explains how things happen through observation rather than asking why through reason and argument
    3. CIt accepts claims on authority and tradition rather than interrogating the assumptions inside them
    4. DIt examines concepts and assumptions through reason rather than settling questions by experiment
  10. 11. Which branch studies the sources, limits, and justification of knowledge?

    1. AEthics
    2. BLogic
    3. CEpistemology
    4. DAesthetics
  11. 12. A thinker studying existence, substance, causality, and free will works in which branch?

    1. AMetaphysics
    2. BEthics
    3. CEpistemology
    4. DLogic
  12. 13. Aesthetics is best described as the branch studying which of the following?

    1. ABelief, doubt, evidence, and knowledge
    2. BInference, validity, soundness, and fallacies
    3. CVirtue, justice, morals, and right action
    4. DBeauty, art, taste, and the sublime
  13. 14. Philosophy of mind is the sub-discipline that studies what?

    1. AEvidence and the theory–observation relationship
    2. BMeaning and the word–world relationship
    3. CConsciousness and the mind–body relationship
    4. DJustice and the citizen–state relationship
  14. 15. Which branch of philosophy studies moral principles, right action, virtue, and justice?

    1. AAesthetics
    2. BEthics
    3. CLogic
    4. DEpistemology
  15. 16. The branch of philosophy that asks 'how should we live?' is:

    1. AEthics
    2. BMetaphysics
    3. CLogic
    4. DAesthetics
  16. 17. Which branch of philosophy studies validity, soundness, formal systems, and fallacies?

    1. AMetaphysics
    2. BEpistemology
    3. CLogic
    4. DEthics
  17. 18. The branch of philosophy that asks 'what is valid reasoning?' is:

    1. ALogic
    2. BEpistemology
    3. CAesthetics
    4. DEthics
  18. 19. According to rationalism, what is the primary source of knowledge?

    1. AAuthority and tradition
    2. BHabit and settled custom
    3. CSensation and reflection
    4. DReason and innate ideas
  19. 20. Which pair of philosophers is most associated with empiricism?

    1. AKant and Hegel
    2. BLocke and Hume
    3. CDescartes and Leibniz
    4. DSartre and Camus
  20. 21. '7 + 5 = 12' is an example of which kind of knowledge?

    1. AA priori
    2. BA posteriori
    3. CContingent
    4. DInductive
  21. 22. Which statement is analytic — true purely by definition?

    1. AAll ice floats on water
    2. BAll humans are mortal
    3. CAll metals conduct heat
    4. DAll bachelors are unmarried
  22. 23. 'Water boils at 100°C' must be checked against the world, making it which type of claim?

    1. AAnalytic
    2. BNecessary
    3. CA posteriori
    4. DA priori
  23. 24. Which ethical framework judges an action solely by its consequences?

    1. AVirtue ethics
    2. BConsequentialism
    3. CNatural law
    4. DDeontology
  24. 25. Dualism holds that reality consists of what?

    1. AOne kind of substance only, physical matter
    2. BOne kind of substance only, mind or ideas
    3. CTwo kinds of substance, mind and matter
    4. DCountless mind-like substances, the monads
  25. 26. Materialism (physicalism) claims that:

    1. APhysical things exist and so do abstract objects like numbers
    2. BBoth mind and matter exist and the mind is a distinct substance
    3. COnly minds and ideas exist and matter is what minds perceive
    4. DOnly physical things exist and the mind is brain processes
  26. 27. A necessary truth is one that:

    1. ACould not have been otherwise in any possible world
    2. BCannot be known before it is checked against the world
    3. CHolds in one time or culture but changes in another
    4. DHappens to be true but could have been false
  27. 28. Deontology judges the morality of an action by what?

    1. AThe character of the agent
    2. BThe duties and rules it fulfills
    3. CThe customs of the agent's culture
    4. DThe consequences it produces
  28. 29. Which of these is the straw man fallacy?

    1. AAttacking the arguer rather than the argument they make
    2. BAccepting a claim because an authority asserts it
    3. COffering only two options when more actually exist
    4. DRefuting a distorted, weaker version of an opponent's view
  29. 30. A deductive argument is valid when:

    1. AIts conclusion follows logically from its premises, even if they are false
    2. BAll of its premises are actually true, whatever form the argument takes
    3. CIt moves from many observations to a conclusion that is only probable
    4. DIt persuades most of its listeners, even if the reasoning is loose
  30. 31. What does soundness require beyond validity?

    1. AThat its premises are accepted by everyone
    2. BThat all the premises are actually true
    3. CThat it takes the form of a syllogism
    4. DThat the conclusion is merely probable
  31. 32. Which pattern correctly states modus ponens?

    1. AIf P then Q; not-Q; therefore not-P
    2. BP or Q; not-P; therefore Q
    3. CIf P then Q; P; therefore Q
    4. DIf P then Q; Q; therefore P
  32. 33. How does deductive reasoning differ from inductive reasoning?

    1. ADeduction's conclusion is drawn from observed cases; induction's from general premises
    2. BDeduction's conclusion is merely probable; induction's is guaranteed by its premises
    3. CDeduction's conclusion follows with certainty; induction's is only probable
    4. DDeduction's conclusion can be overturned by evidence; induction's is fixed once drawn

Go deeper

Answer key

  1. 1. B What is real?Metaphysics asks what is real, studying existence, substance, causality, time, and free will. 'What is right?' belongs to ethics, 'What is knowable?' to epistemology, and 'What is beautiful?' to aesthetics.
  2. 2. D EpistemologyEpistemology owns the question of what we can know and how. Metaphysics asks what is real; logic asks what is valid reasoning; ethics asks how we should live.
  3. 3. C EthicsEthics asks how we should live, studying moral principles, right action, virtue, and justice. Logic concerns valid reasoning; aesthetics beauty; epistemology knowledge.
  4. 4. A What is valid reasoning?Logic asks what makes reasoning valid, studying validity, soundness, and fallacies. The other options paraphrase the core questions of metaphysics, ethics, and epistemology respectively.
  5. 5. C Aesthetics — What is beauty?Aesthetics asks 'What is beauty, and what is art?' The other pairings are scrambled: 'What is real?' belongs to metaphysics, 'How should we live?' to ethics, and 'What can we know?' to epistemology.
  6. 6. D What can we know, and how?Epistemology studies the sources, limits, and justification of knowledge, so its core question is what can be known and how.
  7. 7. B What can we know, and how?Epistemology's central concern is knowledge itself: its sources, limits, and justification.
  8. 8. A What is beauty, and what is art?Aesthetics studies taste, creativity, and meaning in art, centering on the question of what beauty and art are.
  9. 9. B What is beauty, and what is art?Aesthetics is concerned with beauty, taste, and art, unlike the other four branches which ask different core questions.
  10. 10. D It examines concepts and assumptions through reason rather than settling questions by experimentScience answers 'how' through observation and experiment; philosophy examines the concepts and assumptions science relies on, and tackles questions no laboratory can settle. Faith and revelation are religion's tools, and accepting claims on authority is exactly what a philosopher refuses to do.
  11. 11. C EpistemologyEpistemology studies knowledge — its sources, limits, and justification. Aesthetics studies beauty and art; logic studies valid inference; ethics studies right action.
  12. 12. A MetaphysicsThose topics — existence, substance, causality, free will — are the domain of metaphysics, the study of what is real. Ethics concerns right action, epistemology knowledge, and logic valid inference, not the structure of reality.
  13. 13. D Beauty, art, taste, and the sublimeAesthetics studies beauty and art — taste, creativity, and the sublime. The other options list the concerns of epistemology, ethics, and logic.
  14. 14. C Consciousness and the mind–body relationshipPhilosophy of mind studies consciousness and the mind–body link. The other options describe philosophy of language, philosophy of science, and political philosophy.
  15. 15. B EthicsEthics asks how we should live and studies moral principles, right action, virtue, and justice.
  16. 16. A EthicsEthics is defined by the question of how one should live, covering moral principles and virtue.
  17. 17. C LogicLogic studies the forms that make inference reliable, including validity, soundness, and fallacies.
  18. 18. A LogicLogic is the branch defined by the study of valid reasoning and the forms that make inference reliable.
  19. 19. D Reason and innate ideasRationalism (Descartes, Leibniz) holds that reason is primary and the mind contains innate ideas. Sensation and reflection are Locke's empiricist channels; habit and custom are Hume's account of what induction rests on; philosophy refuses to take claims on authority or tradition.
  20. 20. B Locke and HumeEmpiricism — sense experience as the source of knowledge, the mind as a blank slate — is associated with Locke and Hume. Descartes and Leibniz are rationalists; Kant and Hegel belong to the German tradition that came after both camps; Sartre and Camus are twentieth-century existentialists.
  21. 21. A A priori'7 + 5 = 12' is justified without any observation, so it is a priori — Kant used this very example of a synthetic a priori truth, informative yet knowable without experience.
  22. 22. D All bachelors are unmarriedAn analytic statement is true by unpacking its terms: 'bachelor' means unmarried. The other three are synthetic — that humans die, that metals conduct heat, that ice floats are facts about the world learned from experience, and no definition guarantees any of them.
  23. 23. C A posterioriA posteriori knowledge depends on experience and must be verified against the world. A priori and analytic claims need no such observation.
  24. 24. B ConsequentialismConsequentialism (e.g. utilitarianism) judges by outcomes. Deontology judges by duties and rules; virtue ethics judges by character and what a flourishing person would do.
  25. 25. C Two kinds of substance, mind and matterDualism (Descartes) says reality has two fundamentally different substances, mind and matter. The one-substance answers are monism — idealist if the one kind is mind, materialist if it is matter — and Leibniz's countless monads are a third, pluralist picture.
  26. 26. D Only physical things exist and the mind is brain processesMaterialism holds that only physical things exist and mind is ultimately brain processes. Idealism holds the opposite — only minds and their ideas exist — dualism posits two distinct substances, and admitting abstract objects beyond the physical world is exactly what physicalism denies.
  27. 27. A Could not have been otherwise in any possible worldA necessary truth holds in every possible world — a triangle has three sides. A contingent truth happens to be true but could have been false; a claim that must be checked against the world is a posteriori; and something that shifts between cultures or eras is a convention, not a necessity.
  28. 28. B The duties and rules it fulfillsDeontology (Kant's Categorical Imperative) judges by duties and rules, binding regardless of outcome. Consequentialism judges by results, virtue ethics by character, and a culture's customs are the conventionalist answer — none of them a duty that binds whatever the outcome.
  29. 29. D Refuting a distorted, weaker version of an opponent's viewThe straw man refutes a misrepresented, weaker version of the argument rather than the real one. Attacking the arguer instead is the ad hominem; offering only two options when more exist is a false dichotomy; accepting a claim on an authority's say-so is the appeal to authority.
  30. 30. A Its conclusion follows logically from its premises, even if they are falseValidity is about form: the conclusion follows from the premises regardless of whether they are true. Generalizing from observations is induction, which yields only probability; true premises are a matter of soundness, not validity; and persuasiveness is rhetoric, not logic.
  31. 31. B That all the premises are actually trueA sound argument is valid AND has all true premises, which guarantees a true conclusion. Probability belongs to induction, general agreement is not the same as truth, and the syllogism is only one valid form among many.
  32. 32. C If P then Q; P; therefore QModus ponens affirms the antecedent: If P then Q, P, therefore Q. The second is modus tollens; the third is the fallacy of affirming the consequent.
  33. 33. C Deduction's conclusion follows with certainty; induction's is only probableDeduction guarantees the conclusion if the premises are true; induction generalizes from observations to a merely probable conclusion that new evidence can overturn.

Sources

  • Philosophy: A Comprehensive Study Guide

Download all 15 lessons: PDF · EPUB